The topics that helped me start, and why they're speaker notes, not a script.
When I started running 1:1s, I used a template, and my team told me exactly what they thought of it.
The problem: the template did the talking
Going from individual contributor to tech lead meant going from working on my own to a job where talking is the work, and I wasn't used to it. I needed something to lean on in my 1:1s.
So I made a template. It was how 1:1s had always been done with me. I shared my screen and went through every question, filling in the answers, in the same structure every time.
Slowly, I felt the template was getting in the way. People brought just enough to answer the usual questions, so we never covered anything beyond it. I asked my team for feedback on the format. They all said they disliked it.
The fix: a checklist that works as speaker notes
I changed the format and dropped the template. But that meant I now had to keep a conversation flowing, which was easier said than done. My problem wasn't completely solved. I needed a way to guide the conversation and encourage people to open up. I sat down, brainstormed a bit, and came up with a checklist.
A 1:1 should feel like a conversation, and a checklist can help you get one started, but only if it stays out of sight. The checklist is speaker notes. I don't open it and ask the questions one by one, and I don't share it with my team. It's a guide for me. The other person needs to be comfortable and free to bring topics of their own. The checklist makes sure I always have something to say and don't miss the important subjects.
The topics I keep in mind
1. Start with the person, not the work
I start by asking how the person is doing. I ask about their weekend and make some small talk, to get to know them on a more personal level. I ask what's on their mind this week, and about life outside work when they want to share it. I ask whether anything at work is affecting their well-being or happiness, and whether they're happy overall: with the team, the company, working with me, the way we work.
In practice, I ask:
- What was the highlight of the past week or month, and what was the lowlight?
- Is the workload too much or not enough? Does the team feel productive?
- Was there something that stressed them out?
- Are they motivated towards the team's goal? Is something demotivating them, and what can I do about it?
- Is there anything specific they wanted to bring today?
2. Ask what they want, now and later
I ask whether they're happy with what they're doing now, not only where they want to go. It's a shorter-term question. Maybe they want to work on a different subject.
Then I ask about the longer term: whether they have goals they'd like to set for themselves, and where they'd like to be in two years. I ask whether I can help them get there.
I also ask about the things that don't fit into a goal:
- Is there something they've wanted to learn or try but haven't had the time?
- What's their least favourite part of the day-to-day work?
- What could change to make their day better, and what part of the day are they most productive in?
3. Ask about the team
I ask how they're getting along with their teammates, and whether they're happy with the procedures and meetings the team has. I ask whether they would do something differently. I also ask whether the team is getting everything it needs, and what they like or lack about that.
4. Ask about me
I ask what they need from me. What do they like and dislike about how I work? If they were managing the team, what would they do differently?
5. Ask about their working conditions and their concerns
If something changed recently, I ask whether it was for the better or the worse, and whether I can help, for example with equipment. I also ask whether they have concerns about their role, their career, the team's focus or their teammates.
Making it work
I usually run 1:1s monthly. Sometimes the monthly 1:1 is the formal one, because I already see the team in daily meetings, or because I have too many direct reports to meet more often without doing nothing but 1:1s. I adapt to the person. Some prefer them more often and some prefer a longer gap. I still have my own view on how often I should meet someone. It depends on their performance and on how often I feel I need to step in. However often we meet, I end every 1:1 the same way: they shouldn't wait for the next one if they need anything.
I keep a file for each person, and I share it with them. It holds my notes and the actions we agree on, so they can refer back to it. It also gives them the chance to tell me if I misunderstood something.
What changed
Once the template was gone, things came up that it would never have asked about. One person told me they were stressed and busy buying a new property, which explained why they'd seemed a bit more distracted. Another started giving me feedback about colleagues they didn't work with directly.
Asking what people thought of how I work changed things for the whole team. More than one person said our retros were repetitive, and none of them had thought to flag it before I asked. We started rotating through different formats every week, and the team became more open in the retros themselves.
Over time, people began leading the conversation themselves. I guided it and contributed by asking the questions I had prepared that mattered most that month. They enjoyed the conversations more, and all of them said they found them more useful than the old structure.
You stop needing the checklist
The checklist is for getting started. Eventually, you stop needing it. You get used to it, and you end up taking in notes of the topics you want to bring up or follow up on.